Tuesday, March 7, 2017

2017 Midwest Test Fest - All Mountain Masters



2017 MIDWEST TEST FEST

THE All MOUNTAIN EXPERTS
Waists of 80-99

Skis arranged by waist width where possible – in some cases I couldn’t read the specs with my contacts in and on-line info searches yielded little or nothing.

Fischer The Curv GT, 175 cm (112-80-112, 16.0m)
KS:  Woo Hoo!! This is supposedly the closest replacement for my beloved Hybrid 8.0, and boy are they a hoot!  At 80 underfoot, it should be fairly competent in cruddy snow and minimal slush and powder, but that’s not where this ski is gonna shine.  It can be blended into short turns, but it really, really wants to do screaming medium and long radius turns at eye watering speeds.  It rewards good technical skills, but won’t completely spank you for the occasional stance or balance error.  This is a ripping race ski with a soft and cuddly side.

Head Monster 83, 177 cm (125-83-110, 18.0m)
CS:  Head has reworked the Monster series, making it a bit softer and more accessible to a wider range of skiers.  The changes work well, as this version is playful and fun, making it a fantastic front side ski with off piste capability for strong, speedy skiers.

Salomon XDR 84 Ti, 177 cm (131-84-114, 15.0m)
CS:  Short turns are not this ski’s forte, and it lost some grit on the steeps, but it’s a speed racer with plenty of rebound and stability

Volkl Kanjo, 175 and 182 cm (123-84-104, 19.6 and 21.6m)
KS (182):  All new for 2018, this is the unisex version of the women’s Yumi.  When I demoed the Yumi 2 years ago, I found that my I overpowered it and found its speed limit pretty quickly.  Unlike the Yumi, however, the titanal stringer down the center of the Kanjo means it stands up to stronger/heavier skiers and higher speeds. It still has most of the grip and grit of the Kendo/Kenja, but it has a gentler side lacking in the upper level skis.  That said, though, it’s still a pretty burly ski and definitely has that Volkl feel.  Obviously, with a 21.6 meter turn radius, carved short turns are not really its forte.
CS (175):  This one was a letdown for me. It just didn’t have that rippin Volkl feel, and I found it lacking in forgiveness and rebound.
Note:  KS and CS’s opposing feelings on this ski makes me think that length may be an issue, and it suggests that sizing up may be the ticket for the strongest of skiers.

Volkl RTM 84, 177 cm (131-84-112, 17.9m)
KS:  I didn’t demo the 84 this year as I loved it so much 2 years ago it's now my personal daily driver.  I don't believe there have been any changes to it in the interim.  This ski is my happy place on groomers!!
CS:  Wow!  What a great groomer ski!!  This is a short turn mad man, and it had all the oomph that I felt was missing in the wider and softer 86.  Skilled carvers who love speed will really like this ski on the front side of the mountain.
 
Fischer Ranger 85, 166 cm (?-85-?, ?)
KS:  The Ranger 85 was fun and steady in all turn types and sizes!  The 166 cm length was noticeably too short for me, but it still gave me grins in small and medium turns.  Those skiers just beginning to make the jump from skidded to carved turns would do well on this one as it was equally competent on edge or flat and it never got twitchy or grumpy at any speed.

K2 iKonic 85, 177 cm (126-85-114, 17.0m)
CS:  I was told this one would be the fastest ski of the day.  Nice try, but no.  It was best in long and medium turns, but it lacked a tiny bit of grip.
JG:  The iKonic wasn’t great in short turns, but it was otherwise very dependable.

Volkl RTM 86, 182 cm (132-86-114, 19.3m)
CS:  The 86 is the fattest in Volkl’s RTM series, and it’s designed for high speed carving all over the mountain.  The 86 width and tip rocker gives it some amount of crud and light powder performance, but it was most at home on groomers at high speeds.  Like many of Volkl’s high-end skis, it lacks forgiveness for skier error and short turns at slow speeds.  The 86 is a nice ski, but I was really hoping for more and it just wasn’t there.

Line Sick Day 88, 172 cm (127-88-113, ?m)
NW:  This one was too long for me, and I found it super squirrelly.  I couldn’t get off it fast enough.

Rossignol Experience 88, 182 cm (135-88-124, 17.0m)
KS:  The 88 is super damp and forgiving!  Carved short turns took some work, but medium and long turns of any style and at any speed were a breeze.  It crept down the steeps with skidded short turns and flew trough blue screamers with equal ease and competence.  Cruddy piles over scratchy hard pack was handled so smoothly I didn’t even notice the change in texture.  Damp, smooth, and stable are the key words for this one.

Fischer Ranger 90, 182 cm (122-90-111, 18.0m)
CS:  The Ranger 90 was a damp, forgiving, capable all mountain ski, equally at home in short and long turns.  This one was more fun than I was expecting.

Volkl Kendo, 177 cm (127-90-110, 20.8m)
CS:  Anyone who has skied and loved the Mantra, and is looking for a little narrower, more carving oriented version – this is its little brother, and it will give you everything you’re looking for!  Just like the Kenja above, the Kendo got top marks across the board for strong skiers.

Nordica Enforcer 93, 170 cm (?-93-?, ?)
KS:  The Enforcer has 2 sheets of metal and a solid wood core making it a powerful and versatile ski for most conditions.  It is fairly damp and prefers to be driven with authority in medium and long turns at moderate to high speeds.  It had the power to easily whip through the afternoon crud piles.  Lighter skiers or women looking for a more forgiving version should try the Santa Ana 93, which has only one sheet of metal and a core with balsam stingers for a softer, lighter ski.

Atomic Vantage 95, 178 cm (133-95-115.5, 16.8m)
CS:  This ski is really speedy!! It rocked medium and long turns at high speeds, and had plenty of grip and forgiveness.

Fischer Pro Mtn 95, 178 cm (137-95-122, 18.0m)
CS:  This one came out of nowhere, leaving me with a big grin, and earning the gold star of the day for me!  It excelled at all turn types at all speeds – it’s the whole package!!!

Dynastar Legend 96, 178 cm (?-96-?, ?)
KS:  The Legend series is back for 2018, and the 96 looks to be just the ticket for lighter or more relaxed skiers.  It’s super light and responsive with very little rebound, but it suffered a bit when pushed hard.  For my weight, it felt very ripply underfoot and the tips flapped constantly, although they never made the ski bounce out of the turn.
CS:  So smooth!!!  This one gets high marks all the way around.  Wow.

Icelantic Pioneer 96, 172 cm (131-96-118, 17.0m)
KS:  The Icelantic skis are by far the prettiest skis we tested!  Given the dimensions and the reputation of Icelantic, I really expected to love these skis.  I was impressed that the demo guys were doing edge work on the skis when we got there.  That said, though, I found the Pioneers to be super stiff and very unforgiving.  They were damp and confidence inspiring at speed, but I absolutely could not get them to skid at all.  I have no idea if that was a design issue, an edge issue, or a tuning issue, but I couldn’t get them to do anything beyond carve medium radius turns.  In all, it was a very scary ride!!

Elan Ripstick 96, 181 cm (134-96-113, 18.0m)
KS:  I skied this one earlier in the year while it was still a prototype and was completely impressed with its light weight, snappy rebound, and solid grip.  It had all the crud busting and back side capability of the Ripstick 106, while adding the grip and stability of the Amphibio 88.
CS:  You can ski anywhere with this ski and have fun!  It wasn’t fantastic in short turns, but ripped larger turns at really high speeds.  It lacks a bit of forgiveness and grip on the steeps.

Volkl 90-Eight, 156 (W) and 177 cm (133-98-116, 14.6 and 20.1m)
KS:  This was another ski that I tried 2 years ago and really disliked the construction, finding it bouncy, rattly, and unpleasantly stiff.  Just like the Head Joy series, all the Volkl skis with the 3D Ridge construction have had core and construction changes, and I was ready to give them a second look.  Again, just like the Joy series, the construction updates have totally changed the way the skis feel, in a VERY good way!!  With a 20.1 meter turn radius, the 90-Eight does not excel at short turns, but in medium and long turns on groomers, it was a rocket ship.  The ski is now more forgiving and well balanced, with plenty of grit for high speed carving.  Yee Haw!!
NW:  The 90-Eight skied a lot like my full camber Auras – solid and just goes through anything.

Blizzard Bonafide, 173 and 180 cm (133-98-119, 6.5m)
KS (173):  Holy WOW!!  Scratchy hard pack, piles of slushy crud, knee-deep powder, slow skidders, and high speed arcs were all handled with equal aplomb!  If I was looking for a one-ski-quiver for the Midwest, this would be the one!  Loved. This. Ski.!!
CS (180):  So. Much. Fun.!!  This could be the only ski you need!  This one was a real eye opener for me!  Top marks across the board, with just a tiny ding for forgiveness and short turns.  WOW!!
This was the heavy weight, hard charging skiers’ test fest winner, for both the finesse skier and the power skier.  We liked it enough to take it for some extended exploration around the mountain in all kinds of conditions.  Oddly enough, our scorecards were almost identical, with the finesse skier giving a slight edge in short turns on the 173 length.

Salomon QST 99, 181 cm (138-99-120, 19.0m)
CS:  The QST is calm and predictable, best for skiers who prefer to not really drive their skis.  As a power skier, I found it be missing something.

No comments:

Post a Comment